The Ridges AKA the Athens Lunatic Asylum – Athens, Ohio
When was this "asylum" opened, and what
did it look like? Did it follow Kirkbride's design?

The grounds had a beautiful landscape of hills and trees, gardens, ponds, fountains, and a waterfall. There was a farm with livestock and gardens and orchards
where the patients worked. The facility was built in lavish Victorian-era architecture complete with a ballroom!
The structure of the facility was influenced by
Kirkbride and featured the classic “bat wing” floor plan of male and female
wards with 4 sections each extending from a central administration building, with the more violent patients further away from the administrators.
What was this institution's original intent?
The Ridges was intended for the “treatment of the
insane.” The hope was that the beautiful grounds would help patents with their recovery. The hospital originally primarily served Civil War veterans, children, and
criminals with mental illness. It initially housed 120 patients. But when it
was rebuilt in 1877 after a fire, it could house 852 patients.
Who were the patients there? Do narratives of their
experiences exist?
Initially there were a large number
of Veterans with PTSD, but there were many patients with many different diagnoses. One of the first patients admitted was Daniel Fremau
who believed he was the second coming of Jesus Christ. There was one "famous" case. In 1977 Billy Milligan was admitted after an insanity
plea – the first one in American history to me made for "multiple personality disorder" – for kidnapping and raping three women. His story is
told in the book The Minds of Bill Milligan by Daniel Keyes. There are a few books published about the Athen's Asylum such as Asylum on the Hill, but no published work follows a real patient's experience at Athen's Asylum, so many of the stories of former patient's are now mystery. There are carvings in the walls and windowsills left behind by former patients. One carving reads" I was never crazy."
What was the
patients' experience like in that institution, and did that change over the
course of the institution's history?
The nineteenth century was marked by progressive treatments. The calmer patients participated in recreational
activities like boating, painting, dances, and picnics. They had church
services, plays, and could freely roam the grounds. The twentieth century was a stark contrast to this. Treatments like being submerged in ice cold water, electroshock therapy, and
lobotomies were common. Patients were restrained, made to sleep in group bunks in rooms
intended for one person, and patient care generally suffered. A nurse was sometimes responsible for up to 50
patients at a time!
Did the institution, its services, and patients change over
time?
The population growth in the 1900s led to severe
overcrowding and subsequent decline in quality of care. The hospital was over 3
times capacity with nearly 2,000 patients. It was common for the elderly to be
left there by relatives, parents to commit rebellious teenagers, and for homeless
to take shelter here. Overcrowding led to a return of many previously abandoned
primitive treatments like shock therapy. Lobotomies became all the rage, but
then went out of fashion. The 1960s brought about psychotropic medications and
the “thorazine shuffle” as well as more humane care and more diverse services,
e.g. intellectual disability, drug rehab and geriatrics programs.
How many people lived, worked, and died there?
For many years, the asylum
was Athen’s largest employer. Some were fully trained, some were not. Some lived on the hospital grounds, some did not.
About 2,000 people are
in the burial grounds. Many gravestones are for unknown patients due to missing
records, many gravestones are shared for two patients.
Were bad conditions ever exposed to the public?
How?
A popular ghost story of Margaret Schilling lives on.
She got lost in an abandoned unheated ward and got locked in there and died
from exposure since it was winter. Her body was found weeks later lying on the ground
decomposing with her clothes folded neatly in a pile next to her. When they
tried to clean up the body it left a stain. People take walking ghost tours of
the facility even still and get to see this. But other than that, there wasn't any unique scandal or expose specific to this institution.
Though, Dr Freeman performed hundreds of lobotomies here, more than at any other Ohio institution.
Would you have wanted "treatment" in
this institution?
Nope, sure wouldn’t. Wouldn’t
have wanted to work there either. However, if I had to be a patient there I
would certainly prefer to have been there in the early years (1870s-1900s) when
moral treatment methods were still being utilized.
References:
http://www.forgottenoh.com/Ridges/ridges.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athens_Lunatic_Asylum
http://www.faacofohio.org/history.html
http://www.ohiohistorycentral.org/w/Athens_Asylum
http://www.asylumprojects.org/index.php/Columbus_State_Hospital <-- This one has a training video for staff with footage of the hospital in the 1940s.
Wow! The overcrowding. While I understand why, I don't understand the how. If there were only so many beds, what happened to the others who were admitted? And, then the staff would be responsible for even more patients.
ReplyDeleteAlso, the lobotomies, how was it decided who needed a lobotomy or not? I wonder what the standard was that warranted a patient to have an lobotomy. I don't expect answers, I'm just throwing my thoughts/questions out there.
Thank you for this summary. I struggled to find information when I saw the assignment last night, so I set it aside and am going to attempt to search again today.
Wow! I cannot imagine one nurse who is expected to care for 50 patients. I think it would be difficult to care for 10 patients! There is something very eerie about the beauty of the buildings and landscaping of these institutions mixed with the neglect and often times tortuous treatment of patients.
ReplyDeleteThank you for providing a descriptive view of this place. It is interesting that the more extreme or dangerous patients were farthest away from the administrative building. You would think that would be the closest, but that could also mean that was where most of the horrible treatment was performed.
ReplyDeleteAs I read about Byberry in PA, I was struck by the conditions and how the good intentions of Dorothea Dix became a reality as bad as she was trying to correct. While the original intent of treatment of the insane seems to have been turned into something that is in contrast to the physical surroundings.
ReplyDeleteNancy
It seems like walking ghost tours of insane asylums is quite popular. According to the website, http://1037thepeak.com/this-will-give-you-chills-up-your-spine-tour-this-1842-insane-asylum-in-concord-nh-watch/, a creepy walking tour of the New Hampshire Asylum for Lunatics is also available. Unlike Bethlem, at least the patients are not present to be gawked at for a fee.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great summary of the institution. I appreciate the ghost story that you shared. At Oregon State Hospital, much of the facility is still active, and they actually have a museum on-site. It is interesting what people are curious to know more about around this history. I would like to know what motivates them to visit the museum-- did they have a family member who passed there, are they wanting to know more about the history of mental health, or are they just curious about some of the dark stories that one hears about "insane asylums" (not to mention the popular horror shows and movies that like to use these institutions as the backdrop)?
ReplyDeleteI wrote this blog post about Athens, OH -- Jessica Fossett
ReplyDeleteI'm very curious to know how they described PTSD in Civil War veterans. I believe the diagnosis was really only identified after the Vietnam War, so how did physicians characterize the phenomenon in the late 1800s? Did they directly attribute the symptoms to the War or did they have other additional etiological theories at the the time? I recently read a really interesting article in the New Yorker about how many veterans with PTSD can find comfort in the ancient Greek tragedy plays, written by Sophocles and Euripides. Apparently humans have had some understanding of the psychological trauma of war on warriors, young and old, for thousands of years.
ReplyDelete